That game option is the perfect Starfleet choice, but I think canon of the test was that once you got in close enough to try a rescue it ended up that the Maru was a ruse. Of course if you didn’t do any rescue it would end up being a true ship, but that’s the no-win part. The game allowing a partial rescue made it not a “test”, but an actual reality with some chance. Which was Kirk’s point…reality can hand you many more possibilities than a test ever can.
Yeah canon I believe is you can’t get close enough to transport without violating the neutral zone. So it’s a binary either or choice. You rescue and start a war or you watch those people die.
The latter is what Sulu did, but there’s more backstory to why he made that choice back then. Obviously from the movies he changed as a captain to do whatever it took when the assistance was needed by friends.
That game option is the perfect Starfleet choice, but I think canon of the test was that once you got in close enough to try a rescue it ended up that the Maru was a ruse. Of course if you didn’t do any rescue it would end up being a true ship, but that’s the no-win part. The game allowing a partial rescue made it not a “test”, but an actual reality with some chance. Which was Kirk’s point…reality can hand you many more possibilities than a test ever can.
Yeah canon I believe is you can’t get close enough to transport without violating the neutral zone. So it’s a binary either or choice. You rescue and start a war or you watch those people die.
The latter is what Sulu did, but there’s more backstory to why he made that choice back then. Obviously from the movies he changed as a captain to do whatever it took when the assistance was needed by friends.