this is an interesting question i’ve had banging around in my mind since well before Reddit’s implosion (and Discord’s enshittification), but which seems really worth asking now.

you can’t blame Reddit and Discord or their imitators entirely for these going out of style, but they’ve sure put the dagger in a lot of remaining ones, and i kind of wonder if they’re just in an irreversible and terminal decline a la USENET. i can only name two or three i even consider checking anymore, and i’m not sure how sustainable any of those are long-term.

  • xray@beehaw.orgEnglish
    6·
    1 year ago

    I really hope so. I really miss that feel of the old internet. It’s nice to have an online community where you get to know other users just from seeing their posts regularly. And obviously, I’m all for decentralization at this point after seeing how bad consolidation and centralization of websites has messed up the internet at this point. I still use one forum regularly that’s very active and two others less often that are smaller but have enough active users.

    Obviously, if reddit dies, I could see them making at least a small comeback. But I’m not sure how sustainable they are. It would require several different website owners to make their own websites with different topics of focus. Enough people would have to be able to find the websites in the first place for them to be successful. Like most of the internet, Google as a search engine seems to have gotten worse over the past 5-7 years and it’s harder to find websites, especially smaller, newer websites like a brand new forum. If it’s hard to find, you’re going to be struggling with the network effect for a long time which will cripple growth even further.

    Additionally, without the automatic sorting that reddit and lemmy has, the format of static pages of replies also feels a bit dated now. It’s harder to discover useful/helpful/quality posts without reading through pages of replies. Plus, I don’t know how much money small website owners can realistically make off just putting ads on their website nowadays.

    But I’m rooting for them. I really am.