• Aceticon@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    4 months ago

    As I said, celebrities (famous sports people, actors, comedians) get knighted, probably because giving such awards to people “beloved by the Public” makes the Honors System seem honorable, even though such recipients are a tiny proportion of the whole - this very much dovetails with my point about how putting image management above almost all else is a well entrenched cultural characteristic of the English upper classes: by very publicly giving knighthoods and damehoods to celebrities they’re maximizing the projection of a “good image” for the Honors System whilst minimizing the number of members of the “lower” classes who get it.

    You will notice that in every year’s honors list there’s only one or two knighthoods and damehoods for “celebrities” right next to a much larger number of people getting similar awards whose only “honor” is being upper class and/or faithful servants of the State (and by State I don’t mean Society as a whole, I mean the centuries old power structures of Britain).

    I would say your view of it reflects their great success in using the technique of honoring people “beloved by the Public” to shape the Public’s perception of the Honors System as rewarding merit, all the while the hard numbers show such recipients are but a tiny fraction of the total.

    Beyond that you’ll also see upper middle class people who have been faithful servants of the Establishment get knighthoods (quite common in the Justice System and probably why Sir Keir Starmer got his knighthood), which makes sense as a form of incentivising such people to be faithfull servants of the British Establishment - people within the machinery of the State who express a want for change don’t end up in the Honors List.

    Working Class people who were actual heroes risking their own lives for other people only ever get minor honors.

    • 1371113@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      4 months ago

      What I’m saying is I don’t notice that. Most of the people I see getting honours are regular folks. There’s a few toffs in there and the rest are people who genuinely did something, and they come from all walks.

      • Aceticon@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        3 months ago

        The regular folk who aren’t celebrities get minor honors, not knighthoods, and it gets covered to death in the Press how some fireman or nurse got “an honor” and yet they’re never made “Sir” something of “Dame” something-else - the Press always spins it as a great thing and never mentions it’s only the smallest of honors that they’re getting.

        If you go see the actual list of Knighthoods and Damehoods (and don’t get me started on Lordships), it’s mainly the moneyed, upper middle class - the kind of people who are in the BBC’s Board, Theatre Directors, heads of banks, owners of large companies and so on - and people in senior positions in the State aparatus.

        Call me weird, but I think somebody who risked live and limb to save children from a fire deserves a knighthood much more than somebody who is a CEO of a bank or owner of a supermarket chain.